QuickBooks vs Quicken: Key Differences, Costs, and Which One to Use

Key Takeaways

  • QuickBooks and Quicken are both popular financial management tools, but they serve different purposes.
  • QuickBooks offers robust accounting tools for small and medium-sized businesses, while Quicken is primarily used for personal financial management.
  • When deciding between QuickBooks vs Quicken, the right option depends on what you need the software to do. 
  • Many volunteer-led groups currently use QuickBooks and Quicken, but purpose-built nonprofit accounting software is a third option worth exploring.

QuickBooks and Quicken are two popular financial management tools you’ve probably heard of. But while their names sound quite similar, they serve very different purposes.

QuickBooks is business accounting software, while Quicken is primarily focused on personal finance management. Both can help track income and expenses, but they offer very different features, pricing, and learning curves. 

So which option is the better choice? That all depends on what you want the software to help you manage. 

In this guide, we’ll compare QuickBooks vs Quicken, zeroing in on key features, costs, and who is best suited for each option. We’ll also explore why neither one may be a good fit for HOAs, PTAs, and other volunteer-led organizations, and what these groups may want to consider instead. 

Quickbooks vs Quicken: An At-a-Glance Comparison

QuickBooks and Quicken are both financial management tools, and they have some of the same high level functionality. But there are some big major differences in terms of what these tools can do and who they were built for. 

Here’s a quick snapshot of how the Quickbooks vs Quicken compare. 

FeatureQuickBooksQuicken
Best forSmall businesses and organizations with more complex accounting needsIndividuals, households, and some small businesses
CostGenerally more expensive, with multiple subscription tiersGenerally less expensive, with pricing based on the product and plan
Learning curveSteeper, especially for anyone without formal accounting experience Generally easier to learn for those with no formal accounting experience 
Multi-user accessSupports multiple users, depending on the plan. Adding extra users may require extra fees.Limited multi-user capabilities
Financial reportsBusiness-focused reports, including profit and loss statements and balance sheetsReports focused on spending, budgets, investments, and income
Audit trailBuilt-in audit log in QuickBooks OnlineLimited transaction history and audit capabilities
Handoff to a successorCloud-based access and user permissions can make it easier to transition bookkeeping to a successor May require transferring files and account access

Choosing the right financial software all boils down to how you plan to use it. While QuickBooks offers more advanced accounting features for businesses, Quicken is typically a better fit for individuals looking for a tool to track their personal finances. 

What is QuickBooks?

QuickBooks is a popular accounting software option built primarily for small and medium-sized businesses. Business owners can use QuickBooks to manage their finances, track money coming in and going out, and keep everything organized for tax time. 

QuickBooks offers a wide range of accounting features, including: 

  • Income and expense tracking: Connect bank accounts and credit cards to automatically import and categorize transactions.
  • Invoicing: Create and send professional invoices, track outstanding payments, and send payment reminders.
  • Bill management: Keep track of upcoming bills, due dates, and payments to vendors.
  • Financial reporting: Generate reports such as profit and loss statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements.
  • Bank reconciliation: Match transactions in QuickBooks with bank statements to help keep financial records accurate.
  • Multi-user access: Give employees, bookkeepers, and accountants access to financial information, with role-based permissions

There are several versions of the software available, including the cloud-based QuickBooks Online.

QuickBooks offers a lot of features, which makes it a popular choice for businesses that need more than basic bookkeeping. But its complexity can make the platform difficult for users without formal accounting experience.

What is Quicken?

Quicken is financial management software built primarily for individuals and households. Individuals and households use this popular tool to manage their budgets, keep tabs on spending, and financially plan for the future. 

Quicken offers several features to help users manage personal finances, including:

  • Income and expense tracking: Connect bank accounts and credit cards to track transactions and see where money is going.
  • Budgeting: Create budgets, organize expenses into categories, and monitor spending.
  • Bill management: Stay on top of upcoming bills and payment due dates.
  • Investment tracking: Monitor investment accounts, track portfolio performance, and get a clearer picture of overall net worth.
  • Financial reporting: Generate reports to see how much you’re earning, spending, and saving.

There are multiple versions of Quicken available. While Quicken Classic is primarily desktop-based, other versions are cloud-based. Some versions also offer features for managing a small business’s finances, though they’re not as robust as QuickBooks.

Quicken can be a good fit for individuals and families that want to get a better handle on their finances. It’s less expensive and simpler than QuickBooks, and it doesn’t require accounting expertise to use. While that can be appealing for individuals, Quicken may not offer the capabilities that a growing business or organization needs. 

Quicken vs. QuickBooks: 5 Key Differences

Now that we know the basics of each platform, let’s take a closer look at five of the key areas where QuickBooks and Quicken are different and why those differences matter when you’re looking for the best fit. 

1. Accounting capabilities

One of the biggest differences between QuickBooks vs Quicken is what types of financial management they can handle. 

In general, QuickBooks offers a broader range of accounting tools. Businesses have tools to track income and expenses, send invoices, manage vendor payments, reconcile bank accounts, and generate several different types of financial statements, among other things. Some plans also include features like inventory tracking and project profitability reporting. 

Quicken is mostly focused on managing personal finances, with tools for managing things like budgeting, spending, monitoring investments, and managing bills. While some versions of Quicken include some accounting features for small businesses, QuickBooks offers accounting functionality that goes beyond the basics. 

2. Software costs

Quicken is typically less expensive than QuickBooks, but pricing of both depends on the product and the plan.

QuickBooks Online offers multiple subscription tiers. Subscriptions for small businesses start at $38 for one user, though they sometimes run promotional pricing for the first few months. Prices go up depending on features and user access. There are also add-on services that come with an extra cost. 

Quicken also uses subscription pricing, but its plans are much more affordable. Plans for personal financial management start at $3.99, while plans offering business tools start at $4.99. Quicken Classic Business and Personal, which offers more robust business features, starts at $10.99 per month. 

When comparing costs, it’s important to consider the value of the software and what features you’ll actually use. If you have a business with more complex accounting needs and you’ll use the features offered by QuickBooks, it makes sense to pay the higher price tag. But if you’re simply looking to get a handle on your personal finances, paying for QuickBooks probably isn’t the best option.

3. Learning curve 

It takes time to learn any new software. But in general, QuickBooks comes with a steeper learning curve than Quicken. 

QuickBooks is built for business accounting. If a user isn’t familiar with accounting concepts like accounts payable, accounts receivable, and financial reconciliation, they may have a difficult time getting up and running and using the platform to the fullest. 

Quicken, on the other hand, can be easier to use for people without an accounting background. That said, Quicken’s more advanced investment and business features could take some time to master. 

4. Multi-user access and collaboration

QuickBooks offers some clear advantages for organizations where financial management is shared or regularly handed off to someone new.  

QuickBooks Online allows businesses to grant multiple users access to their accounting records, with permissions that vary by subscription plan. Users can collaborate and work from the same financial information. And if someone leaves or joins the business or organization, their access can be removed or added as needed.

Quicken Classic, on the other hand, is primarily built to be used by one person. Users can access certain information across devices, but it doesn’t offer the same level of multi-user collaboration or role-based permissions as QuickBooks Online.

5. Financial reporting and recordkeeping

QuickBooks and Quicken both offer financial reporting, but the types of reports are quite different. 

QuickBooks provides business-focused reports, including profit and loss statements, balance sheets, and accounts receivable reports. QuickBooks Online also maintains an audit log that helps businesses see what changes were made to financial records and who made them. 

Meanwhile, Quicken offers reports focused on personal income, expenses, budgets, investments, and net worth. Users can see transaction histories and generate reports, but Quicken Classic doesn’t offer the same comprehensive audit trail and user accountability features as QuickBooks Online.

If a business or organization needs detailed financial statements or a clear record of financial activity, QuickBooks may be the better option.

Which is Better: QuickBooks or Quicken?

When you’re deciding between QuickBooks vs Quicken, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice all depends on what you want financial software to help with and how complex your needs are. 

If you run a business and need tools for invoicing, managing bills, and preparing financial statements, QuickBooks is probably your best bet. But if you’re simply looking for a way to stay on top of your family’s spending, budgets, and investments or manage simple financial tasks for your small business, Quicken may be a better choice.

However, if you’re managing finances for an organization that isn’t a business or a household, there’s a third option you may want to consider. 

Is There a Better Option for Clubs, HOAs, and Other Volunteer-Led Organizations?

Quicken is a good option for personal financial management, while QuickBooks is typically a better choice for businesses with more complex accounting needs. But what if you don’t really fit into either category. What if, instead, you’re managing finances for a club, HOA, PTA, or other volunteer-run organization? 

Some volunteer treasurers inherit Quicken from their predecessors. Others opt for QuickBooks because it’s a name they recognize. Either tool can be used to manage an organization’s finances, but neither was built with volunteer-led groups in mind.

QuickBooks offers robust accounting features, which can be great for businesses that actually use them. But all those features make the platform complicated and difficult to learn for a volunteer treasurer without an accounting background. QuickBooks tends to be expensive, too, especially for a group that needs to add access for multiple people, such as officers or committee members.

Quicken tends to be easier for nonprofits to learn and navigate, but its multi-user capabilities are somewhat lacking. This makes it difficult if multiple board members need to collaborate or a new treasurer takes over. 

At the end of the day, neither QuickBooks nor Quicken was built for PTAs, PTAs, clubs, and other similar groups. So for these groups, it’s worth exploring a third option: accounting software for volunteer-run organizations. 

MoneyMinder is one example of purpose-built nonprofit accounting software. It provides volunteer treasurers with easy-to-use tools for creating and managing budgets, tracking income and expenses, collecting dues and donations, and generating financial reports. Treasurers can get up and running quickly, even if they don’t have an accounting background. And they won’t get bogged down with extra features they’ll never actually use. 

The platform also supports multiple users with different permission levels, so board members can all work from the same financial information and everything is organized when a new treasurer steps in. 

Which Option is Right For You? 

QuickBooks can be a strong option for small and medium-sized businesses with complex needs, while Quicken is a better fit for personal financial management. But for HOAs, PTAs, clubs, and other volunteer-led organizations may want to explore another option: nonprofit accounting software. 

If your volunteer-led organization is currently using QuickBooks, learn more about making the switch or check out our straightforward pricing to see if purpose-built nonprofit accounting software might be a better fit for your needs.

Frequently Asked Questions about QuickBooks vs Quicken

Are QuickBooks and Quicken the same thing?

No. While their names sound familiar, QuickBooks and Quicken are two very different financial management tools built and owned by two different companies. QuickBooks was primarily built for business accounting, while Quicken focuses on managing personal finances for an individual or household.

Is Quicken cheaper than QuickBooks?

Yes. In general, Quicken is less expensive than QuickBooks. Both offer subscription plans with multiple tiers and pricing. Quicken’s lower-cost plans are geared toward personal financial management, while QuickBooks typically costs more because it offers more advanced accounting features for small and medium-sized businesses.

Can I use Quicken instead of QuickBooks for my small business?

Possibly, depending on the needs of your small business. Some Quicken plans offer features for managing income, expenses, and invoices for small businesses. However, QuickBooks is typically a better fit if your business needs more comprehensive accounting tools, financial reporting, and the ability to collaborate with other users.

Is QuickBooks or Quicken better for an HOA?

Either of these tools can be used to manage homeowner association finances, but neither was built specifically for HOAs. QuickBooks may be too complicated or costly for smaller HOAs, and Quicken may not offer the collaboration features an association needs. Small or self-managed HOAs may find that purpose-built HOA accounting is a better fit.

Is Quicken or QuickBooks better for a PTA?

Both QuickBooks and Quicken can be used to track a PTA or PTO’s finances, but neither was built with volunteer-led parent groups in mind. QuickBooks is often too costly and complicated for parent-led organizations, but Quicken’s limited multi-user capabilities make collaboration and treasurer transitions challenging. Purpose-built PTA accounting software may be a better fit for volunteer treasurers that need to track fundraising income, manage budgets, and prepare financial reports.

Leave a Comment







This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.